Skip to main content

HUD is Mandating Westchester County to Meet the Settlement Requirements



In a rare move, HUD sent Westchester County notice that it has one month to come up with a plan to comply with three major requirements of the 2009 settlement. Failure to do so, Westchester will permanently lose millions in grants from HUD.  One of the requirements involves both a ban on discrimination based on income and ending segregation or exclusionary zoning. As a result, Westchester County stands to lose an estimated $7.4 million in federal HUD funding for failing to comply with the terms of the Fair and Affordable Housing Settlement.

In 2009, the county was facing crippling fines for having taken tens of millions of federal housing dollars while falsely claiming it had complied with fair-housing mandates. In settling the case, the county agreed to build hundreds of affordable units, analyze how exclusionary zoning and other obstacles blocked fair housing, and take steps to overcome them. The County was also supposed to promote a law to forbid landlords from discriminating against tenants who use government vouchers to pay rent.

However, in 2010, when legislators passed the bill protecting tenants, Astorino vetoed it, and then tried to argue that the county had met its obligation to promote the law. The courts have ruled otherwise. The 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a District Court decision that held that the county violated the settlement when Astorino vetoed a bill to prohibit landlords from discriminating against renters using government income such as Section 8 or Social Security to pay their rent, known as the source-of-income legislation.
Astorino vetoed the legislation in 2010, saying it was flawed and would saddle landlords with unnecessary regulation. The veto put the county in breach of the 2009 settlement, which calls for the development of 750 units of affordable housing in predominantly white communities. As the 2nd Circuit noted, you can’t veto a bill and “promote” it at the same time!
HUD’s stripping Westchester of federal funds will be an unprecedented move. HUD has been criticized for its failures to take actions to enforce the fair housing laws. Considering the fact that this issue has dragged on for more than three years, critics have argued that enforcement and compliance actions were long over due. HUD’s ultimatum seems to have paid off. Astorino agreed last Wednesday to sign the fair housing bill he vetoed in 2010 if the county Legislature passes it again.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"Pinklining"? Innovative way to deny women home loans

From redlining to  “pinklining,” a term most people have probably never heard, is hurting women and especially women of color.  The term comes from the 1970's term   redlining . T he term used by governments, agencies, banks and other lenders to deny people of color access to mortgages and credit. Those in charge of public policy and lending practices would draw a redline around certain neighborhoods with high concentrations of minorities and deny them financing and other forms of credit if they lived within those lines. Now, more specifically lenders are using the term "pinklining" ala redlining to identify neighborhoods and deny woman of color the chance to buy homes. Is There a Gender Gap in Home Equity Loans? (investopedia.com)

News Roundup: March 15-26

NFHA President Testifies Before House Judiciary Committee (Reading the full testimony is strongly recommended for anyone interested Fair Housing issues.) On March 11, Shanna Smith of the National Fair Housing Alliance (NHFA) testified before the House Judiciary Committee's Subcommitte on the Constitution, Civil Rights and Civil Liberties, with a presentation titled "Protecting the American Dream: A Look at the Fair Housing Act." The testimony emphasizes that in spite of our efforts, the nation still falls "dramatically short of reaching the actual goals of the Fair Housing Act" which is designed to "eliminate housing discrimination and to promote residential integration." "While people are working together in greater numbers than ever before--many go home each night to racially segregated neighborhoods." Shanna "explores the nature and extent of housing discrimination as it is manifested today, how enforcement action is moving

Homebuyers, Know Your Rights, Pending Changes to the Hosuing Law:

  The Fair Housing Act prohibits housing discrimination in the sale, lease, purchase,   investment or loan process, based on race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, or national origin, and have recently added protection for housing discrimination based on gender  identity and sexual orientation. The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD)  enforces the Act through the Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity office (FHEO). However, the  Fair Housing Act does not protect transactions or leases involving for sale or for rent by owner  properties and some owner-occupied buildings. Currently, a bill (the “Equality Act”) is waiting  to pass the Senate, which would amend civil rights law to ban discrimination on the basis of  sexual orientation, sex, and gender identity in credit and housing, employment, public  accommodations, public education, federal funding, and the jury system. This article discusses  certain LGBTQ homebuyer statistics, warning signs of housing disc